Tyce Ortman REALTOR

By Tyce Ortman | July 20, 2026

Here’s the mistake I see Sioux Falls buyers make over and over: they negotiate hard for a price reduction, get it, and then find out at closing that it barely moved their monthly payment.

A $10,000 price cut on a $350,000 home feels like a win. It’s a big, round number. It shows up on the purchase agreement. But once it runs through a 30-year amortization at today’s rates, it’s worth about sixty bucks a month. Meanwhile, that same $10,000 — asked for a different way — could have cut your payment by $162 a month permanently, or by more than $400 a month during your first year in the house.

Same concession. Same seller. Wildly different outcomes for you.

With the 30-year fixed sitting around 6.5%–6.6% in mid-July 2026 and Sioux Falls inventory tighter than it was a year ago, how you structure your ask matters as much as how much you ask for. Let’s run the actual numbers.

The three-way math on a $350,000 Sioux Falls home

Sioux Falls’ median sale price is running right around $349,000 as of June 2026, so let’s use a clean $350,000 purchase with 5% down. That’s a $332,500 loan. At 6.6%, your principal and interest payment is about $2,124 a month.

Now assume you negotiate a $10,000 seller concession. Here’s what each option actually does:

Option 1 — Take it as a $10,000 price cut. Purchase price drops to $340,000, your loan drops to $323,000, and your payment falls to about $2,063. That’s $61 a month in savings. You also put down $500 less at closing. Over 30 years it adds up to roughly $22,000 — real money, but slow money.

Option 2 — Take it as a permanent rate buydown (discount points). Roughly $10,000 buys about three points on a $332,500 loan, and each point typically shaves around 0.25% off your rate. Call it 6.6% down to about 5.85%. Your payment drops to about $1,962 — $162 a month, every month, for as long as you hold the loan. That’s about $58,000 over 30 years, and it breaks even against the price-cut option in a little over five years.

Option 3 — Take it as a 2-1 temporary buydown. Your rate is cut 2% in year one and 1% in year two, then snaps back to the note rate. On this loan that’s roughly:

• Year 1 at 4.6% — about $1,705/month (saving $419/month, or about $5,030 for the year)
• Year 2 at 5.6% — about $1,909/month (saving $215/month, or about $2,580 for the year)
• Year 3 and after at 6.6% — back to $2,124/month

The full two-year subsidy costs about $7,600, which means a $10,000 concession covers the buydown and leaves roughly $2,400 for your closing costs. That’s the version most buyers don’t realize is on the table.

The buydown money sits in an escrow account at your lender and gets drawn down each month to cover the gap. It’s not a discount your lender is giving you — it’s your seller’s cash, prepaying part of your interest.

How to pick the right one for your situation

The honest answer is that this comes down to two questions: how long will you keep this loan, and how tight is your first year?

Ask for the price cut when the home is priced above what the comps support. This is the one situation where price wins outright. If we’re looking at a house that’s stretching past recent sales in the neighborhood, a price reduction protects you from an appraisal problem. Concessions don’t — a buydown does nothing if the appraisal comes in $12,000 short and you’re suddenly writing a check to cover the gap. A price cut also permanently lowers your loan balance, your loan-to-value, and in most cases your mortgage insurance. When I’m worried about value, I go after price.

Ask for the permanent buydown when you’re planning to stay put. If this is a five-to-ten-year house — and most of the buyers I work with in Harrisburg, Tea, and southwest Sioux Falls are buying with that horizon — the permanent buydown is usually the better dollar-for-dollar trade. It more than doubles your monthly benefit compared to the price cut and keeps paying every month you own the home.

Ask for the 2-1 buydown when the first two years are the squeeze. Growing family, one income temporarily, a business ramping up, a rental you’re carrying until it sells — if near-term cash flow is the actual constraint, $419 a month back in year one is worth more to you than $162 a month spread thin. It’s also the play if you genuinely expect to refinance: if rates drop and you refinance in year two or three, the front-loaded savings are the only savings you were ever going to capture anyway. Any unused escrow money gets applied to your loan balance at payoff, so it isn’t wasted.

Two cautions on the 2-1, and I want you to hear both. First, you still have to qualify at the full note rate, not the discounted one. The buydown makes your payment easier, not your approval. Second, plan for the jump. Lenders see defaults spike right after buydown periods expire, and it’s almost always because someone built their life around the year-one payment. If your budget only works at $1,705 and not at $2,124, the buydown isn’t solving your problem — it’s postponing it.

The ceiling nobody tells you about

Here’s the constraint that catches Sioux Falls buyers off guard: your loan type caps how much the seller can contribute.

• Conventional, less than 10% down: 3% of the sale price. On a $350,000 home, that’s $10,500 — total, for everything.
• Conventional, 10%–24% down: 6%
• Conventional, 25%+ down: 9%
• FHA: 6% regardless of down payment
• VA: 4% plus reasonable and customary loan costs
• USDA: 6% — worth knowing if you’re looking at Hartford, Colman, or the smaller towns where USDA eligibility often applies

If you’re putting 5% down on a conventional loan, you have $10,500 of room and not a dollar more. That has to stretch across your buydown, your closing costs, and any prepaids. It’s also why I’d rather negotiate the structure early than discover the cap during underwriting. And the seller can never contribute more than your actual costs — you can’t pocket the difference.

One more Sioux Falls-specific note: the seller pays the South Dakota real estate transfer fee ($0.50 per $500 of price, about $350 on a $350,000 home) regardless of how we structure the concession. Your closing runs through a title company — First Dakota Title handles a lot of Sioux Falls transactions — and property taxes are paid in arrears here, so the seller’s prorated share comes back to you as a credit at the table. That credit is separate from any concession and shouldn’t be counted against your cap.

What this looks like in a real negotiation

Sioux Falls is moving at about 19 days on market and homes are selling around 98.6% of list, so on a well-priced resale you’re usually not going to win a huge concession. What you can often do is ask for the concession instead of a price cut — sellers frequently prefer that, because it protects their headline sale price and their comps.

New construction is a different story. Builders in Harrisburg, Tea, Brandon, and south Sioux Falls have been leaning hard on buydowns rather than cutting prices, and industry data shows most move-in-ready inventory carries some incentive right now. Builders will almost always structure the money as a rate buydown before they’ll drop the sticker price — and that’s usually fine, because it’s the better deal for you anyway. Just make sure the incentive isn’t tied to a preferred lender whose base rate is a quarter point higher than what you’d get elsewhere. I’ve seen that erase the whole benefit.

The move is to talk to your lender before you write the offer and get real numbers on all three structures for the specific house. Then we ask for the one that actually helps you — with a number that fits under your cap.

Frequently asked questions

Is a rate buydown better than a price reduction?
For most buyers holding the loan more than five years, yes. A $10,000 permanent buydown on a $350,000 Sioux Falls home saves about $162 a month versus about $61 a month for a $10,000 price cut. The exception is when the home may not appraise — then a price reduction is safer, because it lowers your loan amount and protects you from an appraisal gap.

Who pays for a 2-1 buydown in South Dakota?
Usually the seller or the builder, as a negotiated concession. The money is deposited into an escrow account at closing and drawn down monthly to subsidize your payment. Buyers can pay for their own buydown, but it rarely makes sense — you’d be handing your own cash to the lender to lower a payment you’re already making.

What happens if I refinance before the 2-1 buydown ends?
Any money left in the buydown escrow is applied to your loan payoff. It isn’t refunded to you or returned to the seller, but it isn’t lost either — it reduces what you owe. This is why the 2-1 works well for buyers who expect to refinance within a couple of years.

How much can a seller contribute toward my closing costs in Sioux Falls?
It depends on your loan. Conventional loans with less than 10% down cap seller contributions at 3% of the sale price; 10%–24% down allows 6%, and 25% or more allows 9%. FHA and USDA allow 6%, and VA allows 4% plus customary loan costs. The seller also can’t contribute more than your actual costs.

Does a seller concession change what the seller nets at closing?
Yes — a concession comes out of the seller’s proceeds just like a price cut does. The difference is that the sale price on record stays higher with a concession, which sellers often prefer for appraisal and comparable-sales reasons. The South Dakota transfer fee is calculated on the full sale price, so a concession costs the seller marginally more in transfer fee than an equivalent price cut.

Let’s run your numbers

Every one of these calculations changes with your loan type, your down payment, your credit score, and the specific house. The framework holds, but the dollars are yours alone — and the difference between asking the right way and the wrong way on a Sioux Falls purchase is often $100 or more a month, for thirty years.

If you’re buying or selling in Sioux Falls or the surrounding area, I’m happy to walk you through this. Reach out anytime: tyceortman@gmail.com

---

About Tyce Ortman — Tyce Ortman is a real estate agent with eXp Realty serving the greater Sioux Falls, South Dakota area and the Madison community. He specializes in helping first-time home buyers and sellers, with a focus on pricing properties right and finding each client the perfect home. Connect with Tyce at tyceortman@gmail.com.

This article is for general information only and is not financial, lending, or tax advice. Rates, payment figures, and program guidelines are illustrative examples as of July 2026 and change frequently. Consult a licensed lender for figures specific to your situation.