If you’re deciding between building a brand-new house in the Madison area and buying 1413 NE 5th St, the move-in-ready resale wins on speed, finished extras, and price. It’s a 2023-built ranch listed at $339,900 that you can move into now — no six-to-twelve-month build, no bare-dirt lot, and no fresh special assessments to pay down.
Quick Answer: 1413 NE 5th St, Madison is a three-year-old (2023) 3-bed, 2-bath ranch at $339,900 — about $206 per square foot. Buying it instead of building new gets you an already-finished and fenced yard, a deck, a shed, and modern finishes, with no construction timeline, no bare lot to landscape, and no new-build special assessments. It’s near-new without the wait.
Prefer to see it first? Here’s the full video walkthrough of 1413 NE 5th St:
The home at a glance
1413 NE 5th St sits in the Windsor Estates area of Madison and was built in 2023, so it lives like new construction without being a job site. Here’s the short version:
- Price: $339,900 (recently reduced $10,000)
- Layout: 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, single-level ranch — about 1,649 sq ft (~$206/sq ft)
- Lot: 9,748 sq ft (75×130), privacy-fenced, with a deck and a storage shed
- Finishes: quartz kitchen counters with custom cabinetry, marble bathroom counters, LVP flooring, heated floors, vaulted ceilings, formal dining, main-floor laundry, electric fireplace
- Systems: natural gas heat, central air, public water and sewer, 2-car attached garage
- Carrying costs: no HOA; annual property taxes around $3,862
You can see the full listing and all 29 photos here.
What you get here that a new build makes you wait for
This is where an established home quietly beats a brand-new one. When you build, the base price usually gets you the house and a rough lot — and not much else. Everything that makes a house feel finished is extra, and most of it you add after closing, out of pocket.
At 1413 NE 5th St, it’s already done: a fully sodded, privacy-fenced yard, a deck, and a shed are in place. On a new build, those three items alone can run many thousands of dollars and a season of waiting for sod, fencing, and a backyard that’s usable. Add window coverings, finished landscaping, and a poured driveway, and the “cheaper” new build starts closing the gap fast — on your dime, after you’ve already moved in.
The price and “specials” math
At roughly $206 per square foot, move-in ready, this home is priced where a lot of new construction in the area starts before you add the finished extras above. There’s also a line item new-build buyers in South Dakota often miss: special assessments, or “specials” — the charges for streets, water, and sewer that get attached to newer lots and show up on your tax bill for years. An established home like this one typically has that infrastructure already in the tax base, so what you see is closer to what you pay. For the bigger picture, here’s our breakdown of new construction versus resale.
Near-new, without the new-build wait
The usual knock on resale is “older house, older systems.” That doesn’t apply here. Built in 2023, 1413 NE 5th St has young mechanicals, a young roof, and the modern finishes buyers actually want — quartz, LVP, heated floors, marble baths, and vaulted ceilings — so you get the feel of new construction with none of the timeline. No design-center appointments, no weather delays, no “move-in by spring, maybe.” You can close and be in.
When building new still makes sense
To be straight with you: building isn’t the wrong call for everyone. If you want to pick every finish, need a specific floor plan or lot, or want a full builder’s warranty and the newest energy specs, a new build can be worth the wait and the premium — and we list and sell new construction too. The honest way to decide is to run your own numbers, which is exactly what our guide on whether it’s cheaper to build or buy walks through. For most buyers who want to be settled now, without writing checks for a yard and a fence after closing, a finished home like this one is the easier math.
See it for yourself
If 1413 NE 5th St looks like it could be the one, the next step is simple: watch the video tour, view the full listing, or reach out to set up a showing. I’m Tyce Ortman with the Jeff Merrill Team at eXp Realty — call or text me at (605) 413-7903, and if you’re earlier in the process, grab my free Sioux Falls Buyers Guide to get your plan together. Buying in Madison on a tighter budget? Here’s how to buy in Madison with no money down. No pressure either way — happy to help you compare this home against anything you’re building.
About Tyce Ortman
Tyce Ortman is a residential real estate agent with the Jeff Merrill Team at eXp Realty, serving Sioux Falls, South Dakota and surrounding communities including Madison, Brandon, Harrisburg, and Tea. He works with both buyers and sellers, guiding them from first search or listing all the way through closing. Reach Tyce at (605) 413-7903 or through thesiouxfallsguide.com.
Listing details for 1413 NE 5th St (MLS #22607114) are accurate as of publication and subject to change; confirm current price and availability with Tyce Ortman, eXp Realty. This article is general information, not financial advice. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Leave a Reply